01/27AM Update: Excerpts from Internet Monk's
10 Questions for Complementarians:
1. Do you believe that Christian women should only work in the lowest of entry level positions, lest they inadvertently find themselves in authority over a Christian man? Or perhaps Christian women should only work in “women only” organizations? Or perhaps you think that women should not work outside the home at all?
2. Should Christian men avoid working in organizations where somewhere in the organizational hierarchy over them, there might be a Christian woman?
3. If you are pulled over by a female police officer whom you know to be a Christian, how do you make her understand that she has no authority over you (assuming you are male)?
Read more of iMonk's questions here.
12/11/06 Adrian Warnock has a very interesting dialog going about "Women in Ministry" in the comments section of Wayne Grudem Replies to a Critic. Suzanne McCarthy has a connecting post titled Suzanne is Elsewhere. Here is the way that I responded to another blogger last week on this hot topic:
Our discussion began with my question around your view that the role of women in society is different from the role of women in church. Having dialoged with you a bit I have to say that I still have a concern with that view because it presents the church and the kingdom as a sub-culture of society. I think that society is a sub-culture of the kingdom and principles of the kingdom apply to society as a whole. Separating the sacred from the secular is the way that men in past (and present) ages have gained religious power and setup rules to their advantage.And, so as not to confuse anyone, I think that a kingdom calling can either be to a church, a corporation, overseas or at the local McDonalds.
I think that it is a bit more consistent to say that women should not hold leadership positions in society for the same reasons that they should not hold them in church. I think that many church leaders actually believe this to be true but don’t say it because it would expose what they really think about women. For me, I am comfortable knowing that kingdom principles are applicable in society. Whatever God calls a man or woman to is a sacred calling in the kingdom and I don’t think that we need rules about roles to determine if His calling is genuine or not.
How'd I miss this one?!? You're posting too fast...we can't keep up and we're MISSING GOOD STUFF!!
ReplyDeleteGreat questions. I just...I just...I don't know what to say anymore. You know I ranted about this subject several times...
ReplyDeleteFor 15 years I worked at Campus Crusade for Christ. CCC valued prayer and biblical principals, but they did not always have an open mind to change and often took things to the extreme. As time went on and our beloved Bill Bright passed on to Home, CCC realized that they needed to be training new leaders (duh!).
ReplyDeleteWell, in my personal experience there I watched TIME AND TIME AGAIN men given roles in leadership because of their gender rather than their ability. They would be given women on their team that were more qualified, creative or whatever the case may be. This created conflict.
My boss (one of the few younger leaders and number one on my list of people I admire) did the unthinkable - he allowed WOMEN to lead in his department! You should have seen the reaction. I found it entertaining but also sad.
I was honored one day when he sought out my opinion when he was seeking a new Team Leader and he suggested three people, 2 male, 1 female. I immediately chose the female BECAUSE OF HER QUALIFICATIONS NOT HER GENDER! He said he had chose her too and asked me to pray that the two guys that would be reporting to her would accept her authority over them. In the end one did, the other asked for a transfer.
JESUS SAW THE VALUE OF WOMEN and I think many men today are realizing that even though men and women are DIFFERENT they are EQUAL. The goal of CCC is to spread the gospel - so if they are going to let that be hindered by some male egos, they need to move to an all male ministry. Just my opinion.